18 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
PhilO
PhilO
3 years ago

But where’s the murdered mammoth?!?

Ron Miller
Ron Miller
3 years ago

An almost decent cover image, at least as a concept (and even if it does recycle Basil), ruined by inept design and typography.

Ron Miller
Ron Miller
3 years ago

Wait a second! Volume 16?!? There are 15 other ones?

Ron Miller
Ron Miller
3 years ago
Reply to  Ron Miller

Yes, there are 15 other ones…
Yikes.

Ron Miller
Ron Miller
3 years ago

A brief perusal of Mr. Pirillo’s oeuvre is certainly illuminating.

Krij
Krij
3 years ago

Frankly I would read a mystery involving Sherlock holmes and a mammoth

Hopefully it would have a more fun cover than this though

Hitch
3 years ago
Reply to  Krij

I actually read a Holmes-Cthulhu crossover. That’ll show ya. Homes fans will read almost any pastiche if it is well done. I’m not sure about Holmes and this unpictured mammoth, don’tcha know. 🙂

Hitch
3 years ago
Reply to  Nathan

Howdy: this series: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07TB3B9K5 . James Lovegrove, and even though I tend to be a Holmesian “classicist,” (no shipping between Holmes and Watson, both men, boring regular old cases, no “Billy The Kid versus Dracula” stuff) I was desperate and these weren’t bad at all. It’s not as easy as one might hope, to find good Holmesian pastiches.

Dead easy to find sh***y ones. Harder to find really good ones. The Bonnie McBirds are okay.

Myk
Myk
3 years ago
Reply to  Hitch

I’m reading the Shadwell Shadows now. He carved quite a niche out for himself with Holmes. He really does write him quite faithfully to Doyle’s original style, I must say.

Hitch
3 years ago
Reply to  Myk

I like the Lovegroves and I adore that font, too. That’s an old Hallmark font, believe it or not; I had a copy of it made for myself, some years back. It’s effectively disappeared off the face of the planet, interestingly enough.

Have you tried the Bonnie MacBirds? (Love the covers they’ve done for those…)

RK@HM
RK@HM
3 years ago

With special guest Basil Rathbone!

…or Brent Spiner; I could have sworn that was Data in one of his holodeck programs there.

Hitch
3 years ago
Reply to  RK@HM

I agree. That is definitely more Data than Basil.

Hitch
3 years ago
Reply to  Nathan

Yes. The nose is more Basil than Data, but the remainder of the face is more Data than Rathbone. And yes, that skintone definitely skews toward good old Data.

Hitch
3 years ago
Reply to  Nathan

“Data, data! I must have more data! I cannot make bricks without clay!”